Good n Plenty Lancaster: Traditional Amish Food, Tour and History

Foodies unite. It is time to explore new sorts of eating hubs, and this one is for the masses. First of all. I am hardly a foodie. But I also know a good dining experience when I am right in the midst of it. And trust me when I say this, Good ‘n Plenty restaurant in Lancaster County, PA is one of the best eating out experiences my family and I have had in a long time. And if you skim through my site, you will see we are not eating out novices. So this is a pretty strong statement I am making.

kid and girl at Good 'n Plenty Lancaster PA USA

Good and Plenty Restaurant Lancaster

Why masses? Because since the inception of this restaurant, 1969, it has grown from small home-style eating to holding over 600 people in one dining room. And it gets full – often.

Visiting Lancaster County, you can’t avoid Amish culture, traditions, and dining. Even though this restaurant isn’t owned by the Amish, the food is certainly inspired by their Amish cooking style.

Amish food is hearty and country-style. And since we are in the heart of farmland USA, the food is also full of veggies, meat, and poultry.

Related Read: Amish Auction

What is Homestyle Dining (Family Style)

You are probably wondering – what is home style or family style eating, right? I wondered the same thing before we had a chance to do it.

Basically, it is cafeteria-style when you share a table with 20 people. If you are with a group of 20 or more, then you don’t get to sit with strangers who become fun companions while eating a delicious grub. In our case, we were seven, so we had a chance to meet other travelers in the area.

Dining room good n plenty lancaster pa

At first my oldest son was super reluctant to share the table with complete strangers. But, either we got lucky or this was the way things turn out at Good ‘n Plenty, but they were so fun and kind and made our time that much more enjoyable.

Family Style Good n Plenty

However, the food and our waitress was the true attraction.

She was probably my mom’s age, so very grandmotherly. You can tell she loved her job and loved taking on the role of a country granny serving delicious homemade food.

Our waitress good and plenty amish restaurant

Recommended Read: Lancaster Amish Experience at Lancaster County, PA

The Breakdown of our Meal at Good and Planty

Roast Beef salad – I have never tasted this before, but the best way to compare it is to tuna fish salad but instead of tuna you have roast beef. What a great idea.

Roast Beef Salad good n plenty lancaster pa

Cole Slaw – this is no ordinary slaw. It has no mayo. Fresher, less greasy and by far more tasty then the normal one.

cole slaw good plenty lancaster

Bread and butter – the bread is baked on premises, but the best part is what you can put on it. The butter is freshly whipped and they also have this super tasty apple butter (extremely traditional topping in this part of the world).

Apple Butter good and plenty lancaster pennsylvania

Fried Chicken and Mashed potatoes and Browned Noodles – Oh My! – this is my favorite part of the meal. I’m a huge lover of mashed potatoes and fried chicken. But I have never tried browned noodles and if I understand it correctly it’s almost burning the butter and adding sugar to noodles. It was so tasty I had like five helpings. (Don’t tell anyone!)

Home cooking good & plenty restaurant lancaster pennsylvania

Dessert – Amish County is known for homemade pies. The one I recommend everyone try is the Shoofy pie which has a filling of a molasses and raisin mix.

Ice Cream – Ice cream is served on everything here since there are so many dairy farms in the vicinity. Let’s just say, my kids were in Ice Cream heaven.

Ice cream time good and plenty restaurant lancaster

Related Post: Amish Tour in Lancaster

Kitchen Tour of Good and Planty Restaurant

I don’t know how we got so lucky, but I just happened to ask one of the owners if my kids and I can take a tour of the kitchen. If they can feed 600 people in one sitting this homestyled-meal, I wanted to know-how.

Kitchen tour good & plenty restaurant lancaster pa

Plus, my oldest boy has been taking mini-chef courses for the past two years and it was a real cool treat for him to see firsthand how a restaurant works in the back of the house.

Most of these dishes can easily be done at home as long as you have the right bakeware sets. 

Outdoor Fun

After a delicious meal, you have two choices: either go to your car and take a long nap or join in the outdoor fun.

Outdoor fun good n plenty restaurant lancaster pa

There is an adorable playground and petting farm which my kids enjoyed for a long time after our meal.

Feeding Farm good & plenty lancaster pa

This was without a doubt one of our absolute favorite restaurants in the area and if we had more time I would have eaten here over and over again.

If you are visiting Lancaster County and have time for only one restaurant – this is the one!

Recommendation – when you visit this restaurant come with an empty stomach (almost go on a one day fast before hand) this way you will have no guilt at all eating ten helpings of each yummy dish.

Related Read: Doubletree Hilton Lancaster PA Review

Facts About Good and Plenty Lancaster PA and a Bit of History

Fun Facts good & plenty lancaster pa

  • In 1871  the farmhouse that would become Good ‘N Plenty Restaurant was built.

  • Christ and Dolly Lapp purchased the farmhouse in 1969 to make their dream of owning a restaurant come true.

  • The grand opening of Good ‘N Plenty Restaurant was in 1969 with seating for 114 guests and family style dining.

  • In 1971 the Dutch Room was added to increase seating to 600 guests.

  • Christ opened the Bird In Hand Farmers’ Market in 1976.

  • In 1978 a much larger waiting room was added.

  • In 1995 it got another addition and renovation.

  • To accommodate small groups and business meetings the Open Harvest Room was created in 1995.

  • 2008 – Begin menu dining with the introduction of Harvest Platters

Information for Good ‘n Plenty Restaurant

When you come here do the homestyle dining experience. They offer the al carte menu in a different room, but the whole fun is really in the family style eating.

Address: Route 896, Smoketown, Lancaster County, PA 17576

Phone: 717.394.7111

Hours: Open Mon. – Thurs. 11:30AM – 8:00PM; Fri. & Sat. 11:30AM- 8:00PM; Sunday 11:30AM – 5:00PM

Amish Cooking – Good ‘n Plenty Restaurant Review


Last Updated on June 21, 2023

6 thoughts on “Good n Plenty Lancaster: Traditional Amish Food, Tour and History

  1. I haven’t had apple butter in ages! I’m from Pennsylvania and it was a staple in our house. So yummy on toast! The Amish are indeed known for their pies and they are fabulous. You’re making me want to take a trip home!

    1. Hey Jennifer,

      That was one of my favorite things to yet. YOu need to visit home, it’s so fun there.

  2. Wow, looks like a hearty and delicious meal! Crazy how it’s grown to serve hundreds today, so it’s got to be amazing! Thanks for sharing your review!

  3. HM… Amish… One more experience that I have to put on my list. This seems to be fun and different. I never even considered it until now.

  4. My grandmother Ruth Jensen loved taking the family to Good ‘n Plenty from its beginning. Dolly and Christ were amazing. I remember Dolly giving me a book while visiting. We would visit often traveling from Baltimore City. It is a wonderful experience for all ages. The food is absolutely delicious and staff makes you feel like family with open arms. I’m ready for a road trip.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.