Fenicci’s of Hershey Review: Oldest Restaurant in Town

The restaurants I choose during my travels are much more than restaurants. If my family and I are about to spend an entire evening somewhere, it usually needs to be an experience that will be remembered rather than just a place to fill our tummies. Today I’m going to review Fenicci’s of Hershey, sharing my take on it and more.

I focus on this for every place we visit and Hershey is no different. To get the juiciest info from local perspectives I either check out different blogs and websites for that area, but mainly I contact the tourism boards. If you think about it, the people who work there have to be local and have to really know and love their area of expertise. From all my years of travel experience they have always been the absolute best resource (unless you know someone personally who lives in the area you are visiting).

Rick, from Hershey Harrisburg Regional Visitors Bureau, was my go-to guy. Not only was he super helpful, he really got what I was looking for especially when it came to where to eat.

Related Read: Review: Days Inn Hershey, PA

Fenicci’s of Hershey, PA

Fenicci's Restuarant in the evening in Hershey
Fenicci’s of Hershey is one of the most notable restaurants in Hershey, PA. It has a longstanding history in the town and made a phenomenal place for my family to eat during our visit.

Why Fenicci’s Restaurant is as Much Part of Hershey as Hershey Park

Everyone visiting Hershey, Pennsylvania focuses mainly on the Hershey Amusement Park and Chocolate World plus other attractions that all revolve around Hershey. Hershey wasn’t the only one that put this place on the map. Sure he was the biggest influence, but other really fun places need a huge shout-out as well.

And I don’t know about you, but dinner to me is a really important part of traveling, and I mainly gravitate to local’s favorites and restaurants that have a story to tell. Fenicci’s of Hershey, Rick’s main recommendation, was exactly what I had in mind. Plus, the outdoor seating sealed the deal for me.

Our visit to Hershey was extra special. This was more like a family reunion with my parents and brother and his girlfriend. We don’t get to do much-extended family travel these days, so I wanted it to be great. My parents are huge foodies, but will only really remember a restaurant for the actual experience of everything that goes along with it.

family reunion at fenicci's hershey pa
My family and I were sold on Fenicci’s of Hershey because of the outdoor seating, but fell in love with the owners, the ambiance, and the food.

And Fenicci’s Hershey didn’t disappoint. First of all, Phil and Kveta—the owners—and my family totally hit it off due to tons of similarities. Kveta’s mom (who was visiting) speaks fluent Russian since she also came from the old Soviet Union. Phil and Kveta are planning on coming to Guatemala for six months during the off-season and my family and I live in Guatemala. Phil is extremely gregarious and my parents LOVE socializing with the owners (its their thing).

Hanging with the Owner of Fenicci's Restaurant Hershey PA

I loved the outdoor seating and their organic garden where a lot of their herbs and veggies come from for the meals.

Organic Garden at fenicci's hershey pa

History of Fenicci’s Hershey Restaurant and Fun Facts

Why is Fenicci’s Restaurant a historic spot and not just a restaurant?

  • Fenicci’s Hershey has been around since 1935, under the DeAngelis name.

  • This is the oldest freestanding restaurant in Hershey.

  • Mr. Reese (of Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups and more) actually had one of his first candy factories in the basement of this very building

  • They still use all of the original recipes that were brought over from Italy to make their sauces.

Meatballs fenicci's of hershey hershey pa

  • Their famous Upside Down Pizza was introduced to Hershey in 1947.

Upside Pizza fenicci's of hershey

  • Huge portions

Lasagna fenicci's of hershey hershey, pa

  • Over the past 15 years, they were able to raise over $400,000 to help the Penn State Children‘s Hospital and the kids of this community.

Our Food in Fenicci’s Hershey

We ordered the most famous and tastiest dishes. Obviously, we couldn’t skip out on the Upside Down Pizza, meatballs and lasagna. But to start off we also went for the Calamari dish.

Calamari fenicci hershey

The HUGE salad. We actually didn’t know it was going to be huge, we just went for the salad. They aren’t kidding that they are known for their insanely large portions.

Fresh Salad fenicci's hershey

My favorite was the Rosemary Chicken in cream sauce. I’m more of a cream sauce girl.

Rosemary Cream Chicken fenicci's of hershey hershey pa

And, with Phil’s proud recommendation from his organic garden, he brought out the Ghost Pepper chicken wings. Ghost Pepper is considered one of the most spiciest and hottest peppers in the world. I think my dad, brother and oldest son were the only ones brave enough to try it. The guy sitting at the next table, who was a regular of the restaurant, came over to us and said he’s never seen anyone actually order this dish before and was beyond impressed that my ten year old gave it a go.

Ghost Pepper Buffalo Wings fenicci's in hershey

After dinner, we either could’ve ordered dessert at the actual restaurant, but in the same parking lot, also belonging to Fenicci’s in Hershey, is a sweet ice cream parlor. The kids started to get restless so we decided to head over there for more ice cream. Ice cream in Hershey and Lancaster flow like water. I have never eaten so much ice cream in my life.

Dessert Time fenicci's restaurant

My kids don’t mind, I think they can survive on ice cream.

Information for Visiting Fenicci’s Restaurant

I would highly recommend reservations. Especially if you want to sit outside. During the busy season and weekends, the place gets super packed.

Address: 102 West Chocolate Avenue, Hershey, PA 17033

Phone: 717.533.7159

Price: $5 – $30


Monday -Thursday 11 am- 1 am

Friday & Saturday 11 am- 2 am

Sunday noon- 1 am

Hershey’s Oldest Restaurant – Fenicci’s Review

Last Updated on January 30, 2024

One thought on “Fenicci’s of Hershey Review: Oldest Restaurant in Town”

  1. Sounds like an amazing restaurant that will continue to stay the oldest! I love how they use original recipes from Italy and have their own organic garden. Thanks for sharing your review!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.