Visiting Captain Tony’s in Key West: You’ll Love This One

When you think of Key West facts the first things that come to mind are Ernest Hemingway, Drinking, Pirates, and Treasure Hunting. In fact, there are people traveling to the Conch Republic solely to search for bars and drinking nights. That’s why I decided to write this post about Captain Tony’s Saloon, I’ll share with you useful information, facts, and history about.

Ernest Hemingway’s presence is everywhere. Especially in the bars that were rockin’ over 80 years ago, as they are now.

Sloppy Joe’s and Captain Tony’s are the top two best bars in Key West and must-visit when staying in Key West. Ironically enough, Sloppy Joe’s original location is where Captain Tony’s Saloon is located now.

Captain Tony’s Key West

Captain Tony's Key West, Florida - doorway

But Captain Tony’s Key West bar is not only legendary for its history, but also for its design.

inside Captain Tony's Key West bras everywhere
Capt Tony Key West with bras hanging

History of Capt Tony Key West

  • It is a Landmark of Key West and a National Treasure since 1851.

  • It used to be one of the favorite watering holes of legends like Ernest Hemingway, Truman Capote, Tennessee Williams, Shel Silverstein, and Jimmy Buffet.

  • The building where it stands was built in 1851 as an ice house.

  • It also doubled as a morgue before electric refrigeration was invented.

  • The saloon is also the home of Key West’s ‘Hanging Tree.’  This infamous tree was used to hang 17 people until death; 16 convicted pirates and one woman who stabbed to death her husband and two small children.

  • People say that her spirit haunts the saloon to this day.

  • This location became a cigar factory in 1912.

  • In 1933, a local Conch, named Joe “Josie” Russell opened Sloppy Joe’s here.

  • Ernest Hemingway frequented Sloppy Joe’s during this time.

  • In 1938, Josie Russell, in a dispute with the landlord of 428 Greene Street over a $1 rent increase decided to move the entire bar in the middle of the night.

  • In 1940, 428 Greene Street’s landlord leased the building to Morgan Bird, who opened the saloon as the Duval Club.

  • 1958 brought the most recent chapter to 428 Green Street, when Captain Tony bought the bar from David Wolkowsky. Captain Tony’s Key West has been thriving in that location ever since.

entrance to Captain Tony's Key West, Florida

Who is Captain Tony?

  • His actual name was Anthony Tarracino.

  • He was born in Elizabeth, New Jersey.

  • He was a ninth-grade dropout that made whiskey, illegal at the time due to Prohibition, became a gambler and got involved with the New Jersey Mafia who moved to Key West I 1978.

  • In Key West he became a shrimper, charter boat captain, a gunrunner and in 1958, he opened and became the proprietor of Captain Tony’s Saloon.

  • Captain Tony ran for mayor of Key West four times before winning office in 1989.

  • He was the father of thirteen children by five wives.

  • Until his passing in 2008, Captain Tony was a regular fixture at the saloon.

  • His motto was: “All you need in this life is a tremendous sex drive and a great ego, brains don’t mean a shit.”

Ernest Hemingway’s Influence on Key West Drinking and Bar Scene

  • Ernest Hemingway’s watering hole is his favorite bar, owned by his good friend, Josie Russell was “Sloppy Joe’s” (it used to be where Captain Tony’s Saloon is now.

  • Most of Hemingway’s productive years as an author took place in Key West during this time (1928-1938).

  • He met his circle of friends every afternoon at 3:30 – at Sloppy Joe’s Bar (Captain Tony’s Saloon).

  • Ernest Hemingway and his second wife, Pauline, came to Key West from Paris in 1928 on the advice of John Dos Passos, a novelist.

  • Hemingway’s boat captain and favorite bar owner, Josie Russell cashed a $1,000 royalty check for Hemingway when a bank refused, and they became close friends.

  • Russell and Ernest Hemingway would leave Key West for extended fishing trips to Havana.

  • Russell is himself, immortalized as “Freddie”, the captain of the Queen Conch and the owner of Freddy’s Bar in Hemingway’s book “To Have and Have Not”.

  • Hemingway’s drink of choice was Teacher’s (a cheap scotch) and soda.

  • Hemingway loved the bar, and he loved the urinal in the men’s room, a trough.  He always told his buddies that if anything ever happened to the place – he wanted the urinal and when Joe Russell and his patrons moved the bar to 201 Duval Street, the urinal ended up at Hemingway’s house on Whitehead Street.

  • Hemingway met his 3rd wife at Sloppy Joe’s.

  • Shortly thereafter, in mid-1938 Hemingway left Key West and moved to Cuba with her.

Information for Visiting Capt Tony Key West

Address: 428 Greene Street, Key West, Florida

Phone: 305-294-1838

Wonder Which are the Best Bars in Key West – You’ll Love This One

Last Updated on August 2, 2023

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.